ERROR_CLUSTER_DATABASE_TRANSACTION_NOT_IN_PROGRESS - 5919 (0x171F)
An internal cluster error occurred. There was an attempt to commit a cluster database transaction while no transaction was in progress.
Updated: Feb 21, 2026
Technical Meaning
This error code indicates an internal failure in the Windows clustering subsystem. Specifically, it signifies that a transaction attempt was made to commit changes to the cluster database when no active transaction existed.
Error Details
The error ERROR_CLUSTER_DATABASE_TRANSACTION_NOT_IN_PROGRESS (0x171F) is generated by the Windows Cluster Service when an operation intended to commit a transaction is executed in the absence of any ongoing transaction. This can occur due to various reasons, such as incorrect usage or system misconfiguration.
Usage Context
This error typically arises during operations that require database transactions within the clustering environment. Examples include adding or removing nodes from a cluster, modifying cluster resource configurations, or performing other administrative tasks that involve changes to the cluster database.
Developer Interpretation
Developers should interpret this error as an indication of a misstep in transaction management. It suggests that either the transaction was not properly initiated before attempting to commit, or there is a logical flow issue within the application code interacting with the clustering service.
Related Errors
ERROR_CLUSTER_DATABASE_TRANSACTION_IN_PROGRESS(0x1723): Indicates an attempt to start a new transaction when one is already active.ERROR_CLUSTER_DATABASE_TRANSACTION_ABORTED(0x1724): Occurs when a transaction was aborted unexpectedly, leading to an inconsistent state.
FAQ
Q: What does this error mean?
A: This error indicates that a database transaction attempt was made without an existing active transaction in the Windows clustering environment.
Q: How can I prevent this error from occurring?
A: Ensure that all operations requiring transactions are properly managed and that transactions are correctly initiated before attempting to commit changes.
Summary
The ERROR_CLUSTER_DATABASE_TRANSACTION_NOT_IN_PROGRESS (0x171F) is a specific internal error in the Windows clustering subsystem. It highlights issues with transaction management, indicating either an incorrect usage context or misconfiguration within the application interacting with the cluster service.